Common questionProLife team

Live-in caregiver or 12-hour shifts — which is right for us?

Mom can't be alone anymore, day or night. Agencies offer either a live-in aide or two aides on 12-hour shifts. How do families decide which setup is safer and makes more sense?

Post Answer

1 Answer

ProLife best answer

Anna Klyauzova, RN, MSN, MPAProLife team

Live-in care usually fits when your mother sleeps through most nights, while two aides on 12-hour shifts is the safer choice when she needs help or supervision during the night, because under New York pay rules a live-in aide is paid for 13 hours only if she gets 8 hours for sleep (5 of them uninterrupted) and 3 hours for meals; otherwise more hours are owed.

How live-in works: one aide stays in the home, is paid for 13 hours a day, gets meal breaks and sleep time, and needs her own space to sleep. It costs less than 24-hour shift care.

How 12-hour shifts work: two aides rotate, so someone is awake and alert at all times. It costs more but is designed for people who wake often, wander, are at high fall risk at night, or need frequent repositioning or toileting.

How to decide:

  • Track her nights for a week: how often she wakes and what she needs.
  • If she wakes rarely and briefly, live-in may work.
  • If she wakes several times, tries to get up alone, or is confused at night, choose shifts.
  • Reassess when her condition changes.

Think about space: live-in requires a place for the aide to sleep.

At ProLife, 24-hour care with two aides on 12-hour shifts is $840/day (prices can change); see https://prolifehc.com/private-home-care/ or call (718) 232-2777.

Anna Klyauzova, RN, MSN, MPA · Director of Patient Services, ProLife Home Care

Your answer

Join to answer or log in

Related questions

Recent questions

Popular questions

Caregivers and our care team will answer. It’s free. Forum rules

Call (718) 232-2777 Free consultation